In the realm of EDH, a 100-card singleton extravaganza, where legendary creatures reign supreme, the spirit of the format thrives on more than just cutthroat competition. While vying for that coveted victory royale is undeniably thrilling, the beating heart of EDH lies in the joyful chaos and unbridled fun that unfolds around the table. But what separates a lighthearted romp from a cutthroat conquest? What card choices transform a deck from friendly to formidable?

The recent MTGGoldfish Commander podcast with Saffron Olive, Seth, Crim, and Tomer tackled this very conundrum. They delved into the delicate dance between power levels, price tags, and win speeds, ultimately revealing the nuanced tapestry that defines a casual EDH deck.

Price Point: Where Casual Budgets Reign

Let’s face it, dropping a fortune on a deck just to pummel your friends with a turn-three Craterhoof Behemoth might not fly in a casual setting. The price tag shouldn’t cast a shadow of financial disparity over the table. While there’s no hard and fast rule, cards like the infamous $180 Manac Crypt can feel exclusionary and unfair. Remember, casual EDH is about forging memories, not breaking the bank. Opt for budget-friendly alternatives that pack a punch without sending wallets into cardiac arrest.

Power & Disruption: Keeping the Game Balanced

Price isn’t the only factor influencing a deck’s casualness. The potency of individual cards plays a crucial role. Cards like Armageddon, laying waste to precious lands, or Wrath of God, wiping the board clean of creatures, can disrupt the delicate balance of a friendly game. These one-sided power plays can quickly sap the joy out of EDH, transforming it into a one-sided curbstomp. Remember, casual EDH is a collaborative dance, not a gladiatorial arena.

Speed Demons: Slowing Down the Win Train

Combos that warp the game at warp speed can also derail the casual vibe. Instant wins with infinite mana shenanigans or unblockable creature swarms can leave your opponents feeling like spectators in their own game. Casual EDH is about savoring the journey, not reaching the destination in a blink. Embrace strategies that unfold gradually, building tension and excitement with every turn.

The Banhammer of Casual: Respecting the Community Rules

Some cards are so potent or unfair that they’ve earned themselves a one-way ticket to Ban Island in many casual EDH circles. Flash, granting an extra turn before anyone else, is a prime example. While not every banned card is baaaaroken in casual play, understanding your playgroup’s banlist is crucial. It avoids awkward situations and ensures everyone’s on the same page about maintaining a fun and balanced environment.

Powerful Doesn’t Always Mean Problematic

It’s important to remember that not all powerful cards are casual kryptonite. Cards like Time Warp, offering an extra turn, add a touch of excitement without guaranteeing instant victory. It’s a five-mana sorcery that can be countered or interacted with, making it a fair and engaging addition to a casual deck. The key lies in finding cards that enhance the experience, not dominate it.

Ultimately, It’s All About Your Playgroup

Whether a card crosses the line from casual to cutthroat ultimately boils down to the specific playgroup. There’s no universal rulebook, and open communication is key. If you’re unsure about a card’s suitability, don’t hesitate to have a friendly chat with your fellow Planeswalkers. Remember, casual EDH is about fostering positive experiences, not rigid regulations.

Beyond the Cards: Building a Deck for Casual Mayhem

Card choices are just one piece of the casual EDH puzzle. Here are some additional tips to keep the good times rolling:

• Embrace Fun & Flavor: Ditch the min-max mentality and choose a theme or strategy that sparks your inner Timmy! Who wouldn’t want to unleash a deck brimming with adorable squirrels or wreak havoc with a goblin horde?
• Interaction is Key: Don’t just build a solitaire machine. Include cards that allow you to interact with your opponents’ strategies, creating a dynamic and engaging back-and-forth.
• Spice Up Your Deck: Don’t be afraid to get creative. Play the card you have never seen anyone use before. It will basically be a conversation piece!